Posts

Featured Post

ISO 27001 Internal Audit: How to Assess Control Effectiveness Beyond Documentation

-
 A Practical Auditor’s Guide to Moving from “Compliant on Paper” to “Working in Practice” "An effective internal audit does not simply verify that controls are documented. It assesses whether those controls are implemented, operating as intended, supported by appropriate evidence, and addressing the relevant risks." An organization may have a well-written Information Security Management System (ISMS), approved policies, documented procedures, risk assessments, a Statement of Applicability (SoA), and a complete set of audit evidence. On paper, everything may appear to be in place. But an internal auditor should ask a more important question: Does the ISMS actually work in practice, or does it simply look complete on paper? This is where an effective ISO/IEC 27001 internal audit becomes different from a document verification exercise. An internal audit should provide useful assurance about whether the ISMS and its controls are implemented and operating as intended within...
Post a Comment
Read more

How to Test an Information Security Control: Control → Evidence → Test → Conclusion

-
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.     A Practical Auditor’s Approach to Determining Whether a Control Really Works "A control should not be considered effective simply because evidence exists. The real test is whether the evidence demonstrates that the control operated as intended and addressed the relevant risk ." An information security control can look perfectly acceptable on paper. There may be a policy. There may be a procedure. There may be screenshots. There may be reports. There may even be management approval. But when an auditor asks a more fundamental question— “How did you determine that this control actually worked?” —the assessment becomes much more interesting. Testing a control is not simply about collecting evidence and checking whether a document exists. A meaningful control ...
Post a Comment
Read more

When Evidence Exists but the Security Control Is Still Ineffective

-
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.   A Practical Auditor’s Guide to Moving Beyond the Checkbox "Evidence proves that something exists or occurred. Effective controls demonstrate that the intended risk is being addressed consistently." In information security audits , one of the most common mistakes is to equate the existence of evidence with the effectiveness of a control. An organization may provide a policy, system screenshot, log extract, report, approval record, or compliance certificate. At first glance, the evidence may appear sufficient. But an important audit question remains: Does the evidence actually demonstrate that the control is appropriately designed, implemented, operating consistently, and achieving its intended security objective? This distinction is particularly important in BFSI, cri...
Post a Comment
Read more